In the Unit 2 Introduction, I note that the authors suggest that this might be a good time to introduce older students to a logic program as the students will be learning the skills of argumentation and persuasion in their history discussions. Does anyone have a recommendation for a logic program? Has anyone used The Fallacy Detective by the Bluedorns? My rhetoric daughter is 15. Thank you.
Deb,
We've used both The Fallacy Detective and The Thinking Toolbox and greatly enjoyed them. Both of these books focus on informal logic - logical fallacies and basic thinking, arguing, and reasoning skills.
The Bookshelf now carries a formal logic program, Introductory Logic, by James Nance. It is listed in the Enrichment Products.
Susan in La
Mom to 18yods (ToG graduate), 17yods (R), 15yodd (R), 13yodd (D)
Redesigned 2
Thank you, Susan. I appreciate your input!
Debbie
Hey Deb,
A little late, but I thought I would tell you the Fallacy detective is great! Each chapter comes up with a type of fallacy often encountered in arguments. It is certainely not a formal logic program, but I think it is good info. for any age, and easily understood by the average thirteen yr. old. It is a great place to start.
Happy New Year!
Ellen
Ellen,
I appreciate your input. Your enthusiasm about the book has made me excited! I actually have purchased the book and hope to start it with my daughter in the near futue. Thank you for taking the time to share
Debbie
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote