|
|
Books: Why TOG chooses the books it does
Selected books from the
Year 1 Plan as an example.
Questions
about college admissions
Questions
about scheduling
Questions
about choosing and buying books for TOG
Sources for buying books: new and used!
Questions
about teaching methods
Print a 5-page
"Most Frequently Asked Questions" document
I
only have Grammar Stage children. Is TOG right for me?
I
only have one child. Is TOG right for me?
Read
our thoughts about co-ops
|
|
|
Frequently Asked Questions
Books: why Tapestry chooses
the books it does:
Question: While I would certainly agree
that Usborne books are "real books", something I have been
wondering is what type of books are there in addition to these?
Answer: Usborne
books are, to me, the most interesting "type" of text book, or
"spine book." They are real, but usually not in the way that
I've always understood that term (which I *think* Charlotte Mason coined).
Question: With Sonlight
we read a lot of historical fiction, which I can say we have found
very enjoyable. When I think of a literature-based curriculum, it is that
type of book that comes to mind. That may not be accurate but that is what
I think of based on what we have used in the past. Are there books of this
type included?
Answer: For
the Grammar levels, this kind of book constitutes our
"literature" selections. These would be simpler works
written in the historical period we are studying, such as Greek or
Egyptian myths, or simplified versions of the "great books,"
such as A Children's Homer or Black Ships Before Troy.
At the Dialectic-Rhetoric levels, we are truly reading what I would term
the "great books" of Western Civilization: in Year 1 this means:
- The Old Testament
- Macabees
- Selected New Testament books
- Josephus (selections)
- The Odyssey
- The Iliad
- The Aeneid
- Plato's Last Days of Socrates
- Greek Plays: Aeschylus, Euripedes,
and Sophocles
- selections from Aristotle
And more!
In Year 2, the list is dizzying: it
represents a wonderful sampling of the literature of the period 450-1800.
Included are the following:
- Arabian Nights
(selections)
- Justinian’s Law code (selections)
- The Koran (selections)
- Beowulf
- Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales (selections)
(2 weeks)
- Sir Gawain and the Green Knight
- Piers Plowman
- Dante’s Inferno
(selections) (2 weeks)
- Thomas A Kempis’ The Imitation
of Christ
- Malory’s Morte D’Arthur
(selections)
- Cervantes’ Don Quixote
(selections) (2 weeks)
- Moore’s Utopia (selections)
- Spenser’s Faerie Queen
- Luther and His Critics (selections)
- Marlowe’s The Tragical History
of Dr. Faustus
- Shakespeare’s sonnets (selections)
- Shakespeare's Taming of the Shrew
- Queen Elizabeth: The Doubt of
Future Foes, On Monsieur’s Departure, Speech to the Troops at
Tilbury and
- Shakeseare’s Macbeth
- John Donne and George Herbert
(selections)
- William Bradford’s Of Plimouth
Plantation (selections)
- Selections from Roger Williams, John
Winthrop, Anne Bradstreet
- Milton’s Paradise Lost
(selections) (2 weeks)
- Bunyun’s Pilgrim’s Progress
(selections) (2 weeks)
- Jonathan Edwards' Sinners in the
Hands of an Angry God
- Swift’s Gulliver’s Travels
(selections)
- Ben Franklin’s Autobiography (selections)
- Pope’s Rape of the Lock and Essay
on Man (selections)
- Molier’s Tartuffe
- Rousseau’s Confessions
(selections)
- Political Sermons of the Founding
Era (selections) (2 weeks)
- DeFoe’s Robinson Crusoe (2
weeks)
Don't worry! We buy Norton's Anthologies
for most of the above works, and the rest (all but one) are in the
library!
(Return to the top of the page.)
Question: Are works of historical
fiction generally scheduled to be completed in the week that topic is
covered or if it is a lengthy book does it carry over into other
weeks? I am thinking of books similar to Johnny Tremain, By
The Great Horn Spoon, Witch of Blackbird Pond...can you tell what
we've been studying?
Answer: All of these titles are included in
suggested literature selections for Year 2, in the Grammar and Dialectic
levels. We hope this allays fears of whether we are using "real" or
"great" books, or too many Usborne books.
Now, for the next question, which I know will come: no, you don't have
to read them all. And, YES, your average strong reader can really read the
selections listed above in one year. FURTHERMORE, YOU, the busy mom, don't
have to read them! Tapestry Year-Plans will provide
worksheets for your kids, and if you either divvy up discussions in a
co-op, or go to the library and borrow Mr. Cliffs' on each work, or just
use the discussion scripts as written and wing it, your child will get
TONS out of this reading list and (if he's like the kids in Maryland) love
it!
(Return to the top of the page.)
Question: I am considering TOG but am
concerned about reading book sections vs. whole books. I always
encourage my children to complete the book they have started. Reading only
a portion is contradictory to what I want to develop in my children.
Answer: In
many cases, you have the choice of the full version or using Norton's
Anthology based on our child's abilities/time constraints for several of
the heavier literature selections, such as the Aeneid. That means you
get to choose what is best for your family! The pace of Tapestry is
dictated by a tension between two major goals:
- A four-year survey of the Western
Canon: history and literature. This four-year rotation serves
primarily High Schoolers, and can be easily modified. See the Four-Year
Plan page.
- A desire to survey the breadth of the
Western Canon, searching it for three things: what it is, what it says
about mankind, and how it magnifies the glory and wisdom of God.
The works that Tapestry recommends
selections from are those which we believe are better "tasted"
than "consumed" because they are either lengthy, difficult, or
archaic. Most selected works are sampled in the Year 2
plan. In Years 1, 3, and 4, most works are read in their entirety.
(Return to the top of the page.)
While this program was first developed
for moms who have some experience home schooling and have hit a stage in
their family when multi-grade teaching is a must, I have also
had calls from parents of children that are just starting school.
These parents have no books on their shelves and have asked for my
guidance on choosing a core of books to start the program. I have
therefore developed a core list as a sample which I hope will limit
no one and serve many.
Many people have contacted us to request a list of essential books they should buy
for Year 1. We have been very hesitant to write such a list. We
understand that people need to have some idea of how much the whole program will
cost them, but it would be very misleading to come up with any particular list
of books for any given family. Please read our philosophy (below) to find
out why.
Marcia's "philosophy" behind the Resource List is as follows:
First, there was a strong reason why I did not choose one, established, set of books and have all
readings and prepared question/answer scripts come off only those books.
This reason is as follows:
Tapestry was first designed for the mom who has been home schooling
awhile. As I've mentioned in other places, there’s lots of good stuff
on the home school market for moms with one or two kids in K-3 (and Tapestry is
one of them!). But, when you hit the stage where you have, say, a 5th grader, a
3rd grader, a 1st grader, and 2 more in pre-school, I found nothing out
there that's easy to use, comprehensive, and academically satisfying. Some
programs are
easy to use (like workbooks) and comprehensive. Some are academically
satisfying, but are arranged in grade-appropriate guides. As far as I could
find, none were both for teaching true, widespread multi-grades.
As I began to put together something to share nation-wide, my heart
was for you moms first. I wrote
Tapestry to be what I would want if I were buying a program. Among
my top goals were three that relate to book lists:
1) To create a unit study program that would be as inexpensive to use as
possible, but not allow costs to be a controlling factor.
2) To create a program that had some flexibility, but not an overwhelming
list of choices.
3) To create a program that made use of a library when a library was
present, but also presented the option of buying books (currently in
print and easily located) each week, in case the user was a missionary, or lived in a very rural
area.
In order to fulfill those three goals, I wrote Reading Assignments that do
require some time to sift and sort. However, in my mind, the time for making
these choices would fall in the summer, or in vacation weeks between semesters,
not during the busy week-to-week teaching schedule.
Here's how I fulfilled my goals listed above with relation to the book
assignments:
1) Because I wanted to keep expenses for families down, I chose to list a
few, commonly owned, text books (or overview books, or "spine" books).
-
Tapestry covers mainstream topics, not "backwater information."
Different
textbooks have different "flavors" or presentation order, but most
contain the exact same information.
- I did not want to overwhelm you with choices, so
I chose my three-four favorites and provided page numbers for these. The
textbook lines we use for Dialectic and Rhetoric levels are: Bob Jones
University Press World History and United States History,
Streams of Civilization, Volumens 1 and 2, and Western
Civilization by Jackson
Spielvogel.
- But,
you can use Kingfisher if it's on your shelf, even though I don't provide you page
numbers! You won’t have page
numbers all planned for you, but you WILL have topics listed for each week. To
use these books, you will have the added effort of finding the section on
"Egypt: the Nile" in Week 5.
- I truly feel, though, that to ask moms
who may have books bought and paid for to go buy a textbook that I arbitrarily
chose as the "best" one is an unnecessary burden to finances.
2) "The letter (of the law) kills, but
the Spirit gives life." (2 Cor 3:6)
- Different people are going to
love different sources. I don't feel it is serving other moms to dictate that
they must use a certain set reading list.
- It may be more comfortable for
some to have a set choice of books to use, but I believe that the flexibility I
allow will allow the Spirit of God to lead each mom to just the right books for
her children (in terms of both cost and content).
- Listing books in a "week-plan" format,
rather than a day-by-day format allows families to schedule
assignments when they're best for them!
3) Those of you who really like to use a great local library, or who really need
to use the library for financial reasons, will find that if you go to call
numbers I suggest in the Reading Assignment Charts, you'll find not only the
books I chose, but others.
- In some cases, the choices your library offers may be
even better for your children than the ones I found in my library. For these
reasons, library books are noted, and you can always see if your library (which
may not have stocked the same ones mine did) has different books on the topic
you are studying each week.
- Then, for those of you who do live in remote areas
(my friend Jayne uses Tapestry in Togo, Africa), the book list provides
at least one book per week that is available, currently, in print.
- My plan is to
update the list each year so that this will always be the case!
We are in the process of building
pages that will assist those who wish to purchase new books. To see our
partially constructed pages for Year 1, please click here.
To see partially constructed pages for Year 3, please click here.
(Return to the top of the page.)
Here are a few tips about looking at both the Weekly Reading Assignment
Chart and the Resource
List samples posted on this site. (Click on either underlined title to
download the free sample chart or list.)
- First, not all books in the Reading Assignment Charts are listed in
the Resource List. These are books that I found in my
library, but not in the Vendor Catalogs: they are not in print. I
don't want this program to frustrate you by relying on out-of-print
books, so I don't list such in the Resource Lists.
- I keep to an established order to each week's Reading
Assignment Chart
listings. In each grade-level column:
--First, textbooks (or, overview books, or "spine" books) that are
used during many, if not most, weeks of the school year, are listed in the Core
History row.
--Next, books that are in print, and are listed in the Resource List
are listed in the History Supplement section.
--Last, books that were in my library, but are not in the Resource
List, are listed, usually in the "Optional" row. Again, these are valuable to you not only for the suggested
title, but for the call number location. There, you may find other books like
the one I list, if not the one I list.
Another tip about using the Resource List: the books are
sorted first by weeks used, so if you're looking at Weekly Assignment Charts for
Week 6, and want to know if it’s in the Resource List, there’s no need to
search the entire Resource List time and again. There are only a couple of
choices (besides the major text for the entire year) to choose from for Week 6.
Click here for our
recommendations.
(Return to the top of the page.)
|